Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash – The Weird Anime Sort of about Slice-of-Life Fantasy

I guess the general perception of what a slice-of-life is would be contradictory to calling this anime a “slice-of-life”. Well, that’s because it’s not a slice-of-life. But I… I believe having those elements of exploring very mundane stuff within an extraordinary world is fitting enough to call it slice-of-life. The thing about slice-of-life shows is the whole reason I don’t like them is because of the very fact that it bases itself  in real life. I’m engrossed in real life as it is; I am not gonna watch an anime about it (despite having watched over two dozen slice-of-life anime already).

So, Grimgar. Kind of slice-of-life because it explores all these things that you don’t really, like, genuinely explore within another anime. Well, maybe Log Horizon but haven’t watched that quite yet so I don’t know. The survival tactics involved and learning curves that comes with living in a fantasy world are something I have been fascinated with since my early days of watching anime. And, truly, I believe if we’re gonna drown in mass-produced Isekai shows I feel like this is a huge factor we should consider when evaluating them. I am very appreciative that Grimgar brought this to the table although considering this came out early 2016 and there’s been zero talks about it I am guessing this part of it has been discredited as “the boring part” of the series. Which, I mean… Is kind of true?

But not entirely because it’s boring but because I don’t feel like it did its job. I don’t feel that connected with the world because, truth be told, there doesn’t seem to be much of a world. Every time they go back into town it looks like a drawn mess with little to no people actually taking residence within. You got that 1 barmaid in Mary’s female-only lodgings and the guild trainers. I guess everyone just hangs out at the local bar at all points of the day? Most importantly, it doesn’t show me enough of what “every day life” pertains to people. Or like, the concept of Grimgar has drilled in this idea that the party members have to stay in a party and stay in close proximity to one another just to survive. And that doesn’t fit with the idea of a slice-of-life fantasy anime. Like, I want to know what being an actual thief is like. Not what’s obviously just a rogue that Haruhiro’s become. I wanna see more of Moguzo’s ability to cook. I wanna see Yume’s ability to track & hunt. Ranta? I remember he was into a weird way of fishing. It left an amusing impression on me but, somehow, I don’t remember what it was exactly.

Anyways, it’s these things that are not apparent or, well, shown on-screen that I care about more than fighting goblins episode after episode. I get that ‘survival’ is important but these are all aspects of survival anyways. More important ones even. Again, I believe it is very important to feature the intricacies of the world. Of course, the characters should be first and foremost. But you can build up your characters whilst featuring the method in which they choose to live their lives. The way they survive, the jobs they do. All sorts of things that make the world as well as the characters more developed. This is the whole point I even decided to make a post. But there are several major issues I have with the anime itself.

First off, the dialogue is pretty bad. Like, for example, Manato, “The Tomato” (my personal nickname for him), seemed like an absolute sociopath to me. Because his way of speech and mannerisms mirror that of one. He knew exactly what to say to every unique member of his party as if he studied them carefully and molded himself to be the perfect guy. And then there’d be this moment where he talks to the rest of his party and compliment them one by one. But all he did was kind of state what their classes do. Except for Shihoru. When it came to her he complimented her as a person. Which sounded, to me, like he noticed she was crushing on him and wanted to get into her pants. But it turns out he was just.. “a good guy”, I suppose. Another very strange moment of dialogue was when Haruhiro suggested to “change their hunting grounds” because hunting in the same area was getting “boring” because it was starting to get “too easy” and that they need to feel “pressured” for the sake of entertainment. At the time, I was thinking about the whole amnesia bit of the show and wondering if he was being effected mentally. But everyone else kind of just accepted this and they didn’t seem to be losing their minds.

Like, the idea of changing your hunting grounds for the sake of better loot and stuff like that isn’t weird. It’s just the way he phrased it that made him sound like a maniac! Anyway, I thought he was going crazy. In the end, I think they chose these words specifically to make it sound more like a ‘game’. Which I do not care for. In fact, the lengths they go to make it sound more and more like a game are all things I do not care for at all. The main character dumping expositions during fights to clarify that the characters have learned new skills almost every time they go into battle. All silly. I do like the atmosphere of the show. It’s almost melancholic in a way. It just kind of gets ruined in the more light-hearted moments. I remember Haruhiro was snuggling with Yume and I had thought that maybe that could lead to something. Of course, the moment was ruined because Shihoru happened to peak her head out the window and decided to interrupt the whole scene.

Those are my final notes. I like the idea. Poor execution. I wish there was some way Grimgar can retain some level of relevancy so that something like this can be discussed and picked apart more in-depth so that we might learn from it and improve upon it but… Guess it’s impossible by this point. Oh well.


4 thoughts on “Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash – The Weird Anime Sort of about Slice-of-Life Fantasy

  1. I really enjoyed the Grimgar anime and I liked that it took the whole becoming an adventurer thing more seriously and showed some of the genuine struggle for people thrown into the life. I also like how the story deal with death and grief. But, given no follow up anime was forthcoming, Grimgar is one I’ve gone into the light novels to find out what else happens an the story has been amazing. The dialogue still sucks and the ‘comedy’ moments still have a tendency to intrude on what should be fairly decent dramatic moments, but I’ve really enjoyed seeing the world these characters are in expanding and their growth as a party. Honestly, I’d love this series to get another anime because there’s a lot more story to tell, but at this point that seems pretty unlikely.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I would certainly like to see more. If only to see more of the character dynamics involving romance and jealousy and how that might transform the party. And well, just how they might handle the changing relationship statuses of everyone involved. Shit, who knows? How would carrying a baby while having to fight off high-level creatures like dragons and demons? Oh the ideas… They keep coming…

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I just finished the seventh novel in the series though the next three books are only getting released over the next couple of months so I’m going to have to wait for more of the story. But yeah, it just keeps getting more interesting as different parts of the world an characters get explored and some of the conflicts are actually really interesting.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s